Re: An Apology

1

CT's great, with a remarkable roster. But just b/c I'm troubled by the earnestness of your post: Rank 'Em! My list is as follows (grouped, in order):

Group 1: Healy, Davies, Barlow, Waring;

Group 2: Quiggin, M. Farrell, Farrell, Holbo;

Group 3: Brighouse, Hargittai;

Group 4: The Rest.

horizontal rule
2

Good lord, man, you can't do that!

horizontal rule
3

Are you trying to break up CT?

horizontal rule
4

I understand one of them is dating Yoko.

horizontal rule
5

Yoko's a screamer.

horizontal rule
6

I agree, Ted Barlow totally kicks ass.

horizontal rule
7

Hey, I inoculated myself! I said that they're all great; we're talking about very small differences here. Personal preferences, even! And I thought we were all snark, all the time! I guess this is the New Earnestness, the New Decency. Soooorry!

(But admit it; you're list looks just like mine).

horizontal rule
8

I deny a list. (Except that I'd make a group 5, and put Hargittai in it. Take that, New Decency.)

horizontal rule
9

Let's do this for Unfogged posters.

horizontal rule
10

Then we can do it for Unfogged commenters.

horizontal rule
11

I'll go first:

1. Alameida (duh)

2. Labs, Unf, Bob

3. *crickets crickets*

horizontal rule
12

Crickets! We need more crickets!

horizontal rule
13

Actually, Lungfish, you've reminded me to do something I've meant to do:

Total Unfogged posts: 3209

Ogged: 2405, 75%

Fontana: 357, 11%

Bob: 261, 8%

Unf: 146 5%

Alameida: 40, 1%

I guess that makes you a glutton for punishment.

horizontal rule
14

Ranked in order of frequency of posts (roughly posts/week):

Ogged: 21.47

Fontana: 5.95

Alameida: 4.44

Bob: 2.86

Unf: 1.3


horizontal rule
15

I'd like to see a graph of post frequency over time. Anyone?

horizontal rule
16

I'd like an Irish and water, and someone else to write this piece of crap for me. This motion is simply too dull to write. (And a sure loser -- we're just keeping the client happy.)

horizontal rule
17

As far as ranking commentators go, the #1 is easy enough to determine - we all know what that is.

horizontal rule
18

Here's the data as an Excel file. (Numbers bit different because I took out unposted drafts.)

horizontal rule
19

Thanks Michael!

horizontal rule
20

Michael, how many weeks were you figuring? Those posts/week seem high.

horizontal rule
21

I am so going to play with that excel file when I get home.

horizontal rule
22

No, I guess they're right; nevermind.

horizontal rule
23

I just counted the ones listed on the archives. So, I counted 112 weeks as the total lifespan of Unfogged.

horizontal rule
24

ok, neverminding.

horizontal rule
25

LB, you're not having much of a time at work today. Maybe you can spice it up a bit? Write sentences with words the first letters of which spell "this client is a big dummy" or something?

horizontal rule
26

Or perhaps quit my job and regroup with Mr. Breath and the kids, running a fish and chips shack on the beach in the Bahamas.

horizontal rule
27

Or that, though my plan is much easier, and pays better, and can enlist the help of the other commenters.

horizontal rule
28

Here's the data as a pivot table, with one very hard-to-read chart (which you should be able to play with, by adding trend lines and the like). 1MB file.

horizontal rule
29

Grouping by week would make the chart much easier to read, but I couldn't get Excel to do that.

horizontal rule
30

And I am done (or at least I've sent drafts off to the partner. They suck, and I'm going to spend the weekend rewriting them after I get comments back, but I can go home now.).

Life would be so much easier if I weren't such a slow, painful writer.

horizontal rule
31

I'm the same way. Sucks, I agree.

horizontal rule
32

Alameida is the victor in the average length of a post title contest, averaging 25.45 words/title; Fontana Labs is a close second with 24.31. Bob manages 22, while the original co-founders, Unf and Ogged, languor below twenty, with 18.06 and 16.65, respectively.

horizontal rule
33

I think either your calculations or your units may be off.

horizontal rule
34

Duh, characters, not words. Not thinking.

horizontal rule
35

In words (calculated by just breaking on whitespace) it's FL 4, Bob 3.7, Ogged 2.8, Alameida 4.3, Unf 3.2.

horizontal rule
36

The last six posts on CT are all quite good, possibly the best material I've seen there for a month or two.

horizontal rule
37

I dropped Bertram, somehow - probably just before or just after Holbo. (For the sake of historical accuracy - "The Rest" was intended to ref. people I don't remember reading).

horizontal rule